Why does the way a business looks influence what customers think of it?
The way a business presents itself influences how customers judge its quality, credibility and value. Research suggests that visual presentation doesn't simply affect whether people are attracted to a product or service. Under certain conditions, it can actually change how they experience it. To understand why, we need to go back to the 1940s.
Margarine was invented in 1869 as a cheaper alternative to butter. By the 1940s, however, it was still struggling with an image problem. Despite being considerably cheaper than butter, many consumers regarded it as an inferior product and were reluctant to buy it.
Around this time, a manufacturer enlisted the help of a pioneering marketing psychologist named Louis Cheskin, who set out to understand why.
Cheskin conducted an ingenious series of experiments involving butter and margarine. At luncheons, participants were served food prepared with one or the other, without being told which they were eating. The margarine was coloured yellow to resemble butter, and the results suggested that consumers were much more accepting of it when they weren't consciously thinking about its identity.
Other accounts of Cheskin's experiments describe an even more revealing reversal: butter coloured white and presented as margarine could be judged less favourably than yellow margarine presented as butter.
The implications were extraordinary. It wasn't simply that packaging attracted people to one product more than another. Their reported experience of the product itself could be affected by how it was presented.
Cheskin recognised that consumers weren't evaluating flavour in isolation. They were evaluating a complete experience, one shaped by colour, presentation, expectation and the associations those things produced.
He recommended colouring the margarine yellow, wrapping it in foil and giving the packaging a more prestigious appearance, complete with a crown and the name Imperial.
The newly presented margarine performed considerably better in the taste comparisons described in accounts of the experiments, despite the underlying product being essentially the same.
The principle became known as sensation transference: the characteristics and associations of a product's presentation can influence how people perceive the product itself.
You would probably assume that a product's inherent qualities are immutable. We wouldn't even think to doubt that if something has a particular taste, then that taste is fixed and won't change unless another ingredient is added or the product spoils.
And yet, our perception is considerably less straightforward than that.
We don't experience things in complete isolation from their context. We experience them through a complicated interaction between sensory information, memory, expectation and learned associations.
Presentation doesn't merely influence what we think about a product. It can influence what we actually experience.
How can presentation change the way we experience a product or service?
Presentation can change perceived quality by creating expectations before a product or service is experienced. Colours, shapes, packaging and visual design all carry associations that influence our judgements. This is why identical products can sometimes receive different evaluations depending on how they're presented, even when their underlying characteristics haven't changed.
We like to imagine ourselves as rational creatures, weighing up evidence, comparing alternatives and arriving at sensible conclusions. In reality, a considerable amount of our decision-making is influenced by associations, expectations and assumptions we're scarcely aware of making.
Have you ever wondered, for example, why premium ice cream so often comes in round tubs?
There's an interesting body of research into the relationship between shape and taste. People tend to associate rounded forms with sweetness and creaminess, while sharper, more angular shapes are associated with bitterness or sourness.
Research by Oxford psychologist Charles Spence and others has explored these connections, demonstrating how seemingly irrelevant visual characteristics can influence what people expect something to taste like.
Even the shape of an ice cream container can contribute to expectations about its quality. The same product presented in a cylindrical tub rather than a rectangular carton may be perceived as more premium.
Now consider something even stranger.
Have you ever noticed that canned meat sometimes features a small image of a fresh vegetable, like a sprig of parsley, alongside the image of the meat?
What exactly is it doing there?
It tells us nothing about the ingredients, the manufacturing process or how long the contents have been sitting on a supermarket shelf. It doesn't tell us whether the meat tastes good, or whether it's particularly fresh.
Yet that little flash of greenery can suggest freshness, naturalness and something closer to a home-cooked meal.
The marketing consultancy established by Cheskin investigated precisely this kind of visual cue. The tiny sprig of parsley incorporated into the Hormel logo was intended to communicate freshness, bringing a positive association to a product that might otherwise be regarded as heavily processed.
Of course, there's no actual parsley in the meat simply because someone has printed a picture of it on the label. But that isn't the point.
The point is that the image can influence what people expect from the product before they've even opened it.
These associations aren't entirely arbitrary. Many are inherited from earlier cultural experiences, when particular materials, colours and forms genuinely did indicate something about a product's origin, quality or freshness.
Over time, these associations become part of our mental shorthand for judging the world.
It's probably not news to anyone that the way a product is presented can increase the likelihood of it being bought. What isn't widely understood is how presentation can affect our experience of consuming it.
Present someone with an ordinary wine in an expensive-looking bottle and they may genuinely enjoy it more than if the same wine were poured from a plastic jug.
Their opinion isn't necessarily dishonest or affected. Their experience has been shaped by what they expected to experience.
In other words, the way something looks can influence how good we believe it to be, and sometimes even how good it feels to experience it.
Why might your business need a new website even if the existing one works?
Your business may need a new website because a functioning website isn't necessarily an effective one. Customers use visual design, usability and presentation to form judgements about a company's professionalism and credibility. If your existing website looks dated, confusing or poorly maintained, it could be communicating the wrong message about the quality of your business.
Now, what does any of this have to do with your website?
Quite a lot, actually.
Most businesses regard their website as a practical necessity. It's somewhere customers can find them, read about their services, check their prices and make an enquiry.
Provided it performs those functions, the thinking goes, it's doing its job.
But this overlooks a fundamental principle of consumer psychology.
Your website is the packaging in which your business is presented to the world.
For a professional service, where customers cannot easily inspect the quality of what they're buying in advance, that packaging becomes particularly important.
A potential customer looking for an accountant, a builder, an insurance broker or a marketing agency has relatively little objective information on which to judge their competence.
They can read testimonials, examine qualifications and compare prices, but much of their initial impression will be formed through less deliberate judgements.
Does this business look established? Does it appear professional? Does it seem competent, reliable and worth the money?
These impressions are influenced by everything from typography and photography to the clarity of the writing, the organisation of information and the way the website behaves on a mobile phone.
And these judgements can happen remarkably quickly.
A study published in Behaviour & Information Technology found that participants could form consistent impressions of a website's visual appeal after seeing it for just 50 milliseconds.
That's one-twentieth of a second.
Before a customer has read your qualifications, inspected your portfolio or discovered what makes your business better than its competitors, they may already have formed an initial impression of it.
Researchers at Stanford University have also examined the relationship between website presentation and perceived credibility. Their research identified factors such as professional appearance, ease of use, trustworthiness and the avoidance of amateurish design as important influences on how credible a website appears.
A poorly presented website can make an excellent business look amateurish. Equally, a carefully designed website can communicate qualities such as professionalism, attention to detail and credibility before a customer has spoken to anyone.
None of this means an attractive website can compensate indefinitely for a terrible service. Nor does it mean that every business needs an elaborate, expensive website filled with animations and visual effects.
It means that customers don't judge your business solely by the objective quality of what you provide. They also judge it through the expectations created by how you present yourself.
And those expectations can influence how they interpret the experience that follows.
Much like the way margarine can seem more appetising when it's yellow, a service delivered by a business that looks polished, competent and professional may be approached with greater confidence than the same service delivered by a business whose presentation creates uncertainty.
The way your business is presented is not some superficial consideration, separate from the quality of what you provide.
It's part of how that quality is interpreted.
You might have the best product in your market, the most experienced team or the most competitive prices, but if your website communicates something quite different, you're asking potential customers to disregard their own impressions and trust that the reality is better than the presentation.
And as Louis Cheskin discovered more than seventy years ago, that's asking rather a lot.
You could be selling the finest butter in the world, but if you're wrapping it like cheap margarine, don't be surprised when people don't like the taste.
Questions, answered.
Does website design really affect customer trust?
Yes. Research has found that website design influences perceived credibility, with factors such as professional appearance, clear navigation and ease of use contributing to customers' judgements. A website that looks outdated or poorly maintained may create doubts about a business even when the products or services it provides are excellent.
How quickly do customers form an impression of a website?
Research has shown that people can form an initial judgement of a website's visual appeal in as little as 50 milliseconds. These rapid impressions can influence how visitors approach a website, although broader assessments of trust and credibility depend on additional information and experience.
How do I know if my business needs a new website?
Your business may benefit from a website redesign if its appearance no longer reflects your brand, its mobile experience is poor, its content is outdated or visitors struggle to find information and make enquiries. A website should do more than function correctly: it should communicate professionalism, establish credibility and make customers confident about choosing your business.
Sources
- 01Malcolm Gladwell — Blink: The Power of Thinking Without Thinking — Discussion of Louis Cheskin's margarine experiments and sensation transference.
- 02Richard Shotton — The Margarine Test, The Drum — Historical account of Cheskin's experiments and the Imperial margarine repositioning.
- 03Gitte Lindgaard et al. — Attention Web Designers: You Have 50 Milliseconds to Make a Good First Impression — Research into the speed of visual judgements about websites.
- 04Stanford University — Guidelines for Web Credibility — Research-backed guidance on website appearance, usability and credibility.
- 05Charles Spence — Unraveling the Mystery of the Rounder, Sweeter Chocolate Bar — Research discussion of the relationship between shape and taste perception.
- 06CNN — How Packaging Influences Consumer Perceptions — Interview with Cheskin Consulting discussing the Hormel parsley logo and ice cream packaging.
Written by Simon Chadwick






