Why can knowing your business too well make marketing harder?
Knowing your business inside out can make marketing harder because you evaluate it using knowledge and standards your customers don't share. You notice technical details, professional achievements and subtle advantages. Buyers notice whether you understand their needs, can be trusted and will make their lives easier. Both perspectives matter, but they aren't interchangeable.
Imagine two people listening to a new song.
One is a professional music producer with twenty years of experience. They hear the complexity of the arrangement, the sophistication of the harmonies, the quality of the recording and the technical ability of the musicians.
The other is somebody driving home from work.
They hear a song.
The producer might consider it a masterpiece. The driver might change the station after fifteen seconds.
Alternatively, the producer might dismiss the music as repetitive, derivative and embarrassingly simplistic, while the driver decides it's the best thing they've heard all year.
Who's right?
That depends on what we're trying to establish.
If we want to assess the technical accomplishment of the musicians, the producer is probably much better qualified. If we want to predict whether the song will become a hit, things become considerably less straightforward.
The producer has spent years learning to appreciate characteristics that an ordinary listener might never consciously notice. Their knowledge allows them to make sophisticated judgements, but it also changes the experience of listening.
Where one person hears a catchy melody, another hears a predictable chord progression they've encountered a thousand times before.
Something similar happens in almost every profession. The more experienced we become, the more we develop specialised standards for deciding what's good. Over time, those standards become so familiar that we can forget other people don't share them.
A technically exceptional product might be regarded as unremarkable by its intended audience. Something a professional considers rather ordinary might become an extraordinary commercial success.
The qualities that make something excellent within a profession aren't necessarily the qualities that make it desirable to the public.
And understanding that distinction is essential when you're trying to convince people to buy something.
What do strawberry jam and Coca-Cola reveal about what consumers really want?
People don't always choose products based on their technical qualities, and they aren't necessarily good at explaining their preferences. Research suggests that asking consumers to analyse why they like something can sometimes alter their judgement. Meanwhile, commercial failures such as New Coke demonstrate how companies can accurately measure one preference while overlooking others.
In 1991, psychologists Timothy Wilson and Jonathan Schooler conducted a fascinating experiment involving five brands of strawberry jam.
The jams had previously been evaluated by expert food tasters for Consumer Reports. The researchers asked ordinary university students to taste the same products and rank them according to preference.
Interestingly, the students' rankings corresponded reasonably well with those of the experts.
Then the researchers made a small change.
Another group of participants was asked to explain why they liked or disliked each jam before giving their rankings.
The results were striking. Their preferences became considerably less consistent with the expert assessments.
The researchers suggested that asking people to analyse their preferences could interfere with the way they would ordinarily make a judgement. Instead of simply responding to whether they enjoyed something, participants began concentrating on characteristics they might not otherwise have considered particularly important.
Imagine being asked to explain exactly why you prefer one strawberry jam to another. You might start thinking about sweetness, texture, acidity or the intensity of the fruit flavour. You might even begin questioning whether the jam you initially preferred was actually the best.
Yet none of those considerations necessarily entered your mind when you first tasted it.
The experiment didn't prove that instinct is always superior to analysis. It revealed something more interesting: people can struggle to explain their preferences, and the attempt to explain them can sometimes change their judgement.
This presents a rather awkward problem for anyone trying to understand consumer behaviour.
Ask people what they want, and they'll probably give you an answer. But that answer may be influenced by what they think they ought to value, what they can easily articulate or what seems reasonable when they're asked to justify themselves.
The things that actually influence their decisions may be less obvious.
And if consumers themselves can struggle to explain what they want, imagine the difficulties facing businesses trying to predict it.
Consider Coca-Cola.
In 1985, the company developed a drink that performed better in taste tests than the one it had been selling for nearly a century.
Customers hated the idea of it.
Coca-Cola had been concerned about competition from Pepsi, whose sweeter formula frequently performed well in blind taste tests. The company responded by developing a new recipe and conducting extensive consumer research involving approximately 190,000 participants.
The results suggested that people preferred the new formula.
Coca-Cola therefore made what appeared to be a perfectly rational decision: replace its original drink with a version that consumers liked better.
The reaction was extraordinary.
Customers complained in their thousands. Protest groups formed. Some people began stockpiling the original drink. Just 79 days after introducing New Coke, the company announced that its traditional formula would return.
The research hadn't necessarily been inaccurate. Plenty of people really did prefer the new drink when presented with anonymous samples.
But customers weren't simply buying a combination of water, sugar, flavourings and carbonation.
They were buying Coca-Cola.
The familiar taste was part of a much larger experience involving memories, habits, cultural associations and emotional attachments. People valued the product partly because it was something they had known for years.
Coca-Cola had concentrated on making a better-tasting drink without sufficiently accounting for everything else that made people want it.
The company had asked which formula people preferred in a taste test. Its customers were answering a different question entirely.
Making a better-tasting version of Coca-Cola wasn't necessarily the same as making a better Coca-Cola.
And that's a distinction businesses of every size would do well to remember.
How can you see your business through your customers' eyes?
To understand how customers perceive your business, you need to look beyond its technical strengths and consider the problems people are trying to solve. Examine the questions they ask, the objections they raise, what reassures them and what motivates them to enquire. Then use that understanding to shape how you communicate your expertise.
Think about the way you describe your own business.
When somebody asks what makes you different, you probably talk about the things that make you proudest. The experience you've accumulated, the quality of your materials, your qualifications, the technology you use or the standards you maintain.
These are all perfectly legitimate reasons to be proud of what you've built.
But are they the reasons people choose you?
Imagine you run a company specialising in replacement windows.
You've spent years learning about glazing technology, thermal performance, frame construction and installation methods. You know exactly why your products are superior to those offered by your competitors.
Naturally, you want your marketing to explain all this.
Meanwhile, a homeowner visiting your website is wondering whether their house will be warmer, whether the windows will look nice, how much the work will cost and whether the installers will leave the place in a state.
They might be particularly concerned about whether your company is trustworthy. Perhaps they've heard stories about unreliable tradespeople, unexpected charges or installations that drag on for weeks.
The technical qualities of your windows certainly matter. They help deliver the benefits the customer wants.
But you might be devoting half your website to explaining the sophistication of your glazing system while barely mentioning how long installation takes, whether your team cleans up afterwards or what happens if something goes wrong.
Your website could be full of convincing evidence of your professional expertise while overlooking the very concerns preventing somebody from making an enquiry.
Now consider an accountancy firm.
Its partners might be immensely proud of their qualifications, specialist knowledge and sophisticated approach to financial management. Their website naturally reflects these strengths.
A small business owner looking for an accountant, however, might have different priorities.
Will somebody answer the phone when I need help? Can they explain things without making me feel stupid? Will they make sure I don't receive an unexpected tax bill? Am I going to spend every January panicking about paperwork?
The accountant is selling professional expertise. The customer is looking for reassurance, clarity and freedom from anxiety.
They're not necessarily interested in becoming knowledgeable about accountancy. That's precisely why they're looking for an accountant.
Neither business is wrong to emphasise its professional capabilities. But knowing which capabilities matter to the customer, and how to communicate their value, is a different skill.
Your customers aren't studying your business to discover everything that's impressive about it. They're trying to work out whether you can solve their particular problem.
A useful way to think about marketing is as the process of discovering the difference between what a business believes it sells and what its customers believe they're buying.
The window company believes it sells high-quality glazing. Its customers are buying a warmer, quieter and more attractive home.
The accountant believes they sell financial expertise. Their clients are buying confidence that somebody competent is looking after their affairs.
A restaurant owner might believe they're selling exceptional food, while customers are choosing somewhere to spend an enjoyable evening with people they like.
The product and the experience are connected, but they're not identical.
This doesn't mean that quality is unimportant. Far from it. An accountant who doesn't understand tax law won't be particularly reassuring for long, and an expensive window that leaks after six months won't deliver the comfortable home its purchaser was promised.
The product still has to fulfil its purpose.
The challenge is understanding which aspects of that purpose matter to the people buying it.
This is also why simply asking customers what they want isn't always sufficient. As the strawberry jam experiment illustrates, people aren't necessarily skilled at analysing their own preferences.
Effective marketing combines knowledge of the product with research into the audience, observation of customer behaviour and an understanding of the circumstances in which people make decisions.
A professionally designed website, for example, isn't simply the one that its owner likes most or the one that wins the admiration of other designers. It's one that uses professional design, clear communication and an understanding of its visitors to help the right people find what they need and confidently take the next step.
That requires expertise. Just not expertise in the business alone.
And sometimes it requires somebody who's prepared to question things that everyone within the business has long since accepted as obvious.
One of the peculiar things about running a business is how quickly the unfamiliar becomes familiar.
Technical terminology becomes everyday language. Complicated processes become second nature. Differences between products that once required considerable explanation eventually seem self-evident.
You spend so much time working within your industry that you begin to forget what it's like to know nothing about it.
This is perfectly natural. It's also part of becoming good at what you do.
But your next customer might be encountering your business, and perhaps even your entire industry, for the first time.
They won't necessarily understand the terminology you use. They may not appreciate the distinctions you consider important. They might have concerns you've never thought to address because, from your perspective, the answers are obvious.
An outside perspective can expose these gaps.
Somebody unfamiliar with your business might question why you describe a service in a particular way, why important information is buried three pages into your website, or why you're emphasising a feature that customers barely understand.
They aren't necessarily better qualified to run your business. They simply have the advantage of seeing things you no longer notice.
And that can be extraordinarily valuable.
After all, the people you're trying to reach don't have your experience. They haven't spent years developing your expertise or learning the subtleties of your profession.
They're certainly not going to spend twenty years studying your industry before deciding whether to buy from you.
You may know exactly why your business deserves their custom. But if you can't see it through their eyes, you might never understand why they're choosing somebody else.
Knowing your business inside out is an achievement. The trick is remembering that your customers are still standing on the outside.
Questions, answered.
Why is it difficult to market your own business?
Business owners can become so familiar with their products, services and professional terminology that they overlook what potential customers don't understand. They may concentrate on technical advantages when customers are more interested in practical benefits, reassurance, trust or price. An outside perspective can help identify the gap.
Does knowing more about a product make you worse at understanding customers?
Not necessarily. Expertise is valuable for developing, improving and evaluating products. Difficulties arise when specialists assume that customers share their professional standards or knowledge. Understanding a product and understanding why somebody wants it are related but different capabilities.
Do customers always know what they want?
No. Research suggests people can struggle to explain their preferences, and asking them to analyse those preferences can sometimes influence their responses. Businesses should consider what customers say alongside their actual behaviour, questions and purchasing decisions.
What should a small business website communicate first?
A small business website should quickly help visitors understand what the company offers, whether it can solve their problem and why it can be trusted. Professional credentials, technical details, testimonials and case studies can then provide evidence that supports those initial impressions.
How can professional marketing help a business understand its customers?
Professional marketing combines research into customer needs and behaviour with knowledge of the business, its competitors and its market. The objective is to identify what makes the business valuable to its intended audience and communicate that value clearly through its website, advertising and other marketing channels.
Sources
- 01Wilson, T. D. and Schooler, J. W. (1991) — Thinking Too Much: Introspection Can Reduce the Quality of Preferences and Decisions, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
- 02The Coca-Cola Company — New Coke: The Most Memorable Marketing Blunder Ever?
- 03HISTORY — Why Coca-Cola's New Coke Flopped
- 04Gladwell, Malcolm (2005) — Blink: The Power of Thinking Without Thinking
Written by Simon Chadwick






